• Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

dead

Kat is not a trickster for reals. My guess was she was some type of solo. Maybe she was a red lady that visited the wrong person?
Quagmire makes a good point that the trickster doesn't work on wolf kills. So that must mean she was killed by the SK or some villager killed her, like the jailer or witch.
 
Yeah, you've found 2 wolfs in there. So far the 3rd is staying hidden.
Remaining possibilities (assuming dimmerwit isn't a fantastic liar):

Alu
Ben
canadaguy
FR? (if Kat wasn't a trickster as you've claimed)
Quagmire
Smacktard

I'm guessing from benzine's earlier comment that Zell is jailer. Which clears Local.
 
The last I left it, they were leaning towards killing Kat, funny enough.
Pretty cool how that worked out. She didn't get lynched but they still pulled off the trickster move because she died by a not-wolf person. I'm thinking this confirms FR as wolf since you said I mentioned two of them, and Kat is either a town or one of the solos.
 

Christina

Vampire
Queen of the Dead
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
4,270
If they were smart somebody would point out that I checked shortkut and Jon on night 2 and added them to my sus list, and would believe shortkut after he campaigned HARD for Christina and would start lynching Jon.

But so far nope.
By campaigning hard, you mean he said anything what so ever in my defense, which was not allowed yesterday if you did not want to look like a bad guy.
 

Christina

Vampire
Queen of the Dead
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
4,270
I'm...confused. He said stuff in your defense? I remember him begging people to switch their vote to you.
I thought you were talking about Jon. You had said yesterday that if I was a wolf Jon would be to because he came to my defense. Really all he did was point out who was saying what and the possibilities of what, but I think because if your seer with him in it, you tied him to high chance of wolf, when he really wasn't pushing to have me not lynched. Maybe I'm remembering it wrong.
 
I thought you were talking about Jon. You had said yesterday that if I was a wolf Jon would be to because he came to my defense. Really all he did was point out who was saying what and the possibilities of what, but I think because if your seer with him in it, you tied him to high chance of wolf, when he really wasn't pushing to have me not lynched. Maybe I'm remembering it wrong.
Okay sorry for the confusion. I was saying that shortkut campaigned hard to vote you. And my reasoning for Jon was that if you turned out to be a wolf, then shortkut was likely not wolf which casts suspicion on Jon because of my detective check.
 

Christina

Vampire
Queen of the Dead
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
4,270
Wonder how long it will take them before they figure the trickster wolf thing out. Right now they are making some assumptions without doublechecking the rules, and FR is seemingly cleared for now because of it.
Or is there a purpose to not miss leading about it. Benzine has said a wolf and townie are cupided. Whoever that wolf was didn't tell the rest of us, which means they are playing for the cupid win first.

Zell knows better. Which makes me wonder if him and Fool's are paired. Zell would thus know that Kat had the trickster on her. He jails her and kills her to help hide Fool's. Plays along with her being a real wolf. They would know who the other wolf is, but they need the solo killer dead and enough town folks dead first before taking out the last wolf.
 
Or is there a purpose to not miss leading about it. Benzine has said a wolf and townie are cupided. Whoever that wolf was didn't tell the rest of us, which means they are playing for the cupid win first.

Zell knows better. Which makes me wonder if him and Fool's are paired. Zell would thus know that Kat had the trickster on her. He jails her and kills her to help hide Fool's. Plays along with her being a real wolf. They would know who the other wolf is, but they need the solo killer dead and enough town folks dead first before taking out the last wolf.
Oooooh I forgot about cupid! Good theory :)
 

Christina

Vampire
Queen of the Dead
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
4,270
The wolves made me look like a wolf and people believed it?? I feel like I was pretty obviously a solo role. I don't fuck around like that as a wolf, and I'd at least attempt to defend myself as a townie.
I had it figured you were solo of some kind, I just couldn't figure out if it's was killer type or not. The last the wolves were talking about was killing you, but I was thinking you might be solo which would be a waste of a wolf kill.
 
The wolves made me look like a wolf and people believed it?? I feel like I was pretty obviously a solo role. I don't fuck around like that as a wolf, and I'd at least attempt to defend myself as a townie.
Basically as soon as you died Quagmire said "wolf trickster only works if not killed by wolves", and nobody looked any deeper into it after that. Didn't stop to realize that there were TWO kills that night, and you could had still been killed by a non-wolf (jailer Zell) and still been trickstered.
 
I think you're right and Zell is almost certain to have been made part of the cupid team, because he would have realized this (both because he knows the rules better than anyone and has the most experience and also because he's the one who did the death) but he's choosing to run with it rather than point this out to anybody.
 

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,705
I had it figured you were solo of some kind, I just couldn't figure out if it's was killer type or not. The last the wolves were talking about was killing you, but I was thinking you might be solo which would be a waste of a wolf kill.
Good, mission accomplished then.

Why would the wolves attack me in either case? The fool is more helpful to them alive! Silly wolves.
 
Back
Top Bottom